Connecting to Collections Care

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

B72 labeling problems

  • 1.  B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-10-2020 14:39
    I have been using B72 Paraloid lacquer as a labeling base and top coat for archaeological artifacts for years with no issues. Within the past year I have had the same issue with three different batches of B72 (purchased from an archival products supplier at different times). The ink beads on top of the base coat so that it is unreadable. This occurs whether using a Pigma Micron pen or archival ink applied with a pen nib. In the few instances when I was able to successfully get a label on, the top coat "erased" it. I have never had this issue before and now I have it with every batch I try! Has anyone else had this issue or know how to overcome it?

    ------------------------------
    Tamira Brennan
    Curator
    Illinois State Archaeological Survey
    Champaign IL
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-11-2020 09:04
    I have been very unhappy with B72 lately.  I think it is about time the conservation/preservation community comes up with a better barrier coat.

    ------------------------------
    Evelyn Fidler
    Collections Manager
    Kings Landing
    Prince William NB
    (506) 476-1905
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-11-2020 09:44

    I switched from using B72 to using Lascaux a year or so ago. I am really happy with it. I use it the same way as I used B72.

    https://www.talasonline.com/Lascaux-Adhesive

     

     

    Caitlin Heusser

    Museum Curator

    Town of Windsor | Parks, Recreation, and Culture

    116 5th St. | Windsor, CO  80550

    Dir: 970-674-3524 | Off: 970-674-3500

    www.windsorgov.com

     






  • 4.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-11-2020 11:29
    Can Lascaux be used as a base and top coat, or is it strictly an adhesive? Do you know of any published evaluations of this product's archival qualities?

    ------------------------------
    Tamira Brennan
    Curator
    Illinois State Archaeological Survey
    Champaign IL
    (618) 453-5031
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-18-2020 15:57
    Curious to know which Lascaux acrylic adhesive type you are using: 303HV, 498 HV  or 498-20X?

    ------------------------------
    Noel Valentin
    Permanent Collection Manager
    El Museo del Barrio
    New York NY
    (212) 660-7120
    nvalentin@elmuseo.org
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-21-2020 13:03
    Some important Lascaux facts for those who are looking into purchasing some for labelling: 

    Lascaux 303 HV will remain permanently tacky. It is not suitable for labelling because it will gather dust and dirt and become obscured over time. 

    Lascaux 498-20x contains Xylene to make it dry faster. This would make it less suitable for applying to painted or varnished surfaces, or plastics, etc. 

    Lascaux 498 HV would be my go-to choice in this scenario. It doesn't have the same stellar aging characteristics as Paraloid B72 (which is why B72 is always considered the gold standard in conservation), but its working properties are excellent and you don't have to deal with any solvents.

    ------------------------------
    Megan Narvey
    Outreach Conservator
    Minnesota Historical Society
    Saint Paul MN
    6512593468
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-13-2020 16:29

    Hello All,

     

    When I arrived at my current position my predecessors were using a product called Lascaux 498HV to adhere labels to objects. Since I was used to B-72 I inquired about this and was told that a conservator recommended it during a collections care workshop that they attended. We print our object numbers on archival paper and then apply them to the objects using the Lascaux so I'm not sure how it reacts with pigma pens. It looks almost like Elmer's glue when applied but dries clear. I'd be curious to hear the communities feedback on this product. It can be purchased on Talas as well as art supply stores.  

     

     

    Diana Welsh

    Collections Manager

    The Indian Museum of North America®

    Crazy Horse Memorial Foundation®

    12151 Avenue of the Chiefs

    Crazy Horse, SD 57730-8900

    605-673-4681  Ext. 256

    diana.welsh@crazyhorse.org

    www.crazyhorsememorial.org

     

    "Never Forget Your Dreams®" - Korczak Ziolkowski

     






  • 8.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-11-2020 12:47
    Hi Tamira,

    Thank you for reaching out to the C2CC Discussion Board with this! I am the current Connecting to Collections Care monitor.

    I am in the process of reaching out to experts in the C2CC community to answer your questions. In the mean time, I'm wondering what concentration of B-72 you've been using and in what solvent?

     I will get back to you with recommendations from the C2CC experts as soon as possible.

    Warm regards,
    Victoria

    ------------------------------
    Victoria Kablys
    Conservator
    Royal Saskatchewan Museum
    Regina SK
    (306) 787-2667
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-14-2020 09:55
    My institution uses Paraloid B-72 in Acetone as a base and top coat. I've found that in the last few years it's thinner and often requires several base coats. Further, if applied to porous archeology objects it bubbles. This is also new within the last few years. I've heard of folks printing labels and adhering them with B72 but I cannot fathom that the current makeup of it would allow for that. I'd love something comparing B-72 and the Lascaux adhesive mentioned. I'd like to find a reliable method for marking with ink and one for adhering labels.

    ------------------------------
    Jessica Bowes
    Museum Technician
    Fort Stanwix National Monument
    Rome NY
    (315) 338-7738
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-15-2020 09:38

    I suspect that some of the problems people are experiencing (bubbling, inability of ink to adhere) are due not to the Paraloid B72 itself, but rather the dilution percentage and the solvent utilized for the dilution. Conservators generally purchase B72 in solid bead form, and dissolve it in a solvent of choice, depending on the working properties and application needs. I suspect most of the people using this for labelling are buying a ready-diluted formulation.

    As far as 'bubbling' goes, it is natural that rough surfaces or those with porosity will cause air to be trapped under the dilute, liquid acrylic which will try to come to the surface as air bubbles. The issue is one of application and formulation rather than a problem with the B72 itself.

     

    Sincerely,

     

    Douglas Sanders

    Paper Conservator

     

    IU Libraries Preservation

    ALF Building

    2850 East Discovery Parkway

    Bloomington IN 47408

    (812) 856-4463

     






  • 11.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-13-2020 16:29
    I am also interested in this information. I use Paraloid B-72 as a barrier and top coat and label using archival ink and pen nibs. I have only had this problem if I apply the top coat to quickly to the number after labeling. And, what you described always occurs when I use a Pigma Micron pen for labeling. I've given up on those pens as it never turns out looking clean or clear.

    ------------------------------
    Laura Belani
    Collection Manager
    Bowers Museum
    Santa Ana CA
    (714) 567-3652
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-14-2020 13:25
    I had similar problems using Paraloid B72 as a topcoat, but now I get better results using the Faber-Castell Pitt Artist Pen for marking and Golden Self-leveling (acrylic) Gel as a topcoat. The gel is cloudy when wet but dries to a clear, level finish, with no bubbling.

    ------------------------------
    Cindy Opitz
    Director of Research Collections
    Museum of Natural History and Old Capitol Museum
    The University of Iowa
    Iowa City IA
    319-335-0481
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-16-2020 10:34
      |   view attached

    Posted on behalf of:

    Katherine Ridgway

    State Archaeological Conservator
    Virginia Department of Historic Resources

    "I've attached an article from the JAIC on labeling artifacts in case that helps. If they have been using the same lacquer and pens for years, there's been no change in their process, and no drastic environmental changes (extra high humidity), it makes me think that there has been some change in the formulation of the lacquer or the ink or both. Maybe a new solvent or some other change? It might be worth contacting the manufacturer to see if they have any information on updated formulas that they are using. I found that it took so long for the various layers and ink to dry that it ended up not being worth the wait. Now I put a printed label (archival paper) between layers of B-72 and it makes the process much faster. It also helps with legibility since my handwriting isn't the greatest. If there is bubbling that affects the legibility of the label, I use a brush with some acetone to pop the bubbles (not too much) and I can usually see immediate improvement. Archival pens on archival paper should also work. I hope this helps and let me know if you have any other questions!"



    ------------------------------
    Victoria Kablys
    Conservator
    Royal Saskatchewan Museum
    Regina SK
    (306) 787-2667
    ------------------------------

    Attachment(s)

    pdf
    braun_2006_labeling.pdf   1.54 MB 1 version


  • 14.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-16-2020 13:30
    I also use B-72 on acid free printed paper.  I found it very important to use the brush in one direction, otherwise you can get an uneven, lumpy coating.  Hope this helps!






  • 15.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-17-2020 09:41
    We also use paper labels with B-72 in acetone (B-67 in naphtha for some items). We've had a few instances of bubbling, but not often enough to be a problem. It's important to not over-work the coating, which can result in a lumpy appearance due to the acetone's rapid evaporation. Setting the paper label in place quickly and soaking an ample topcoat into the paper helps keep the label from coming off after it's dry.

    Vernon G. Weckbacher
    Archivist/Curator
    Mission Historical Museum
    900 Doherty
    Mission, TX, 78572
    956-580-8646





  • 16.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-17-2020 12:16
    I'm curious Vernon what factors you are weighing when you decide to use B67 vs B72?  Is it the solvent, the workability, the surface of the object you are applying it to?  As a paintings conservator my experience of B67 used as a varnish is one that is checkered.  In general B72 has better aging characteristics.  B67 can crosslink and while you can find aged B67 coatings that remain soluble I also have experienced B67 coatings that are tough to remove.  I am wondering if there is a better choice for you when you do not want to use B72 but having a better idea of your concerns are would help.  I should also add that B67, like B72, has been promoted by the conservation community and is probably still in use, it is only with more time that we have begun to experience some of its less desirable characteristics.  

    Best,
    Heather

    ------------------------------
    Heather Galloway
    Conservator, Fellow
    Galloway Art Conservation
    1305 W 80th St. Suite #225
    Cleveland, OH 44102
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-17-2020 17:01
    We have used B-67 in naphtha for labeling items where the surface might be damaged by acetone, particularly painted surfaces and finished wood. If better alternatives have been developed, I would be interested in hearing about them. As always, when in doubt, we tag items or use some other inert or non-intrusive means of marking.

    Vernon G. Weckbacher
    Archivist/Curator
    Mission Historical Museum
    900 Doherty
    Mission, TX, 78572
    956-580-8646





  • 18.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-18-2020 09:57
    Dear Vernon,

    Like yourself, I too would also approach the use of B72 on painted and/or varnished surfaces with some caution as acetone can sometimes soften these layers.  I'm not someone who has had to carry out labeling personally, but I suspect that some of your colleagues here who have been working with the Lascaux adhesives have been given this advice with similar solvent sensitivity concerns in mind.  Lascaux 498 is a synthetic polymer but one that has been modified so that it in a water based dispersion.  Diana Welsh does a great job of describing it, it will be white in appearance in the jar (just like Elmers) but will dry to a clear film.  Lascaux 498 can be thinned with water but once dry it cannot be removed with water.  If the surface you are applying it to is not too porous it can often be peeled or rolled off once dry just like you peel dried Elmers off your hands.  While it is considered an adhesive it can create a topcoat. That coating will be softer and flexible than B72.  While B72 may smear your ink because of the solvents I would imagine that if Lascaux is applied too wet it could swell your paper label.  Taken straight from the bottle I doubt that would be a problem but again like B72 as that bottle sits after it is opened it will start to thicken and you may have to dilute it slightly to make it workable.   

    I am on the advisory committee for C2CCare and we have been watching this thread with interest and are hoping to develop some programing around this topic, so stay tuned!  

    Thanks for bringing ever greater insight to my understanding of the challenges you face!

    Best,
    Heather

    ------------------------------
    Heather Galloway
    Conservator, Fellow
    Galloway Art Conservation
    1305 W 80th St. Suite #225
    Cleveland, OH 44102
    ------------------------------



  • 19.  RE: B72 labeling problems

    Posted 09-17-2020 13:25
    Thank you Katherine Ridgeway and Victoria Kablys for posting my 2007 JAIC article on applying paper labels using B-72.  I meant for this article to answer questions such as this, and for the most part, I believe it has aged well, and should still be helpful to our peers.  It makes me happy to see it freely distributed by AIC far and wide, and I hope it has helped people with similar problems.  

    I have refrained from commenting in this group until now because the initial question was unclear to me about what the exact problems they were asking about were.  I think other commentators have correctly pointed out that sometimes end-users technique or procedures might be the problem, and if that is the case, I think a careful reading of my article should be helpful.  In recent years I have fielded similar questions, and it appears what sometimes is at issue is that users might not be using a true xerographic process.  Some ink or toner manufacturers might be adding ink or other unstable dyes to xerographic processes, which might be causing some users that follow my articles instructions to see some bleeding when the labels are wetted with B-72 in acetone.  If that is what you are experiencing, I might suggest that you find an alternative printing brand or system to produce your labels, or if all else fails, try different solvents that dissolve B-72 but do not affect xerographic labels.  For example, you might be able to print your labels using an inkjet printer (which would not be stable in acetone), but then photocopy the labels using a xerographic office printer (which should produce a label that is stable when immersed in acetone).  

    Most xerographic toners use polystyrene as the binder, so solvents that dissolve polystyrene at higher concentrations should be avoided, particularly toluene or xylene.  At times when I have a difficult substrate to apply a label to, or have experienced bleeding in what I assumed is a xerographically-printed label, I have used B-72 dissolved in petroleum ether.  I'm not a big fan of this solvent due to its inherent flammability and toxicity concerns, but I believe if handled properly it can be a solution in difficult circumstances.  Please note that petroleum ether is not an actual ether (rather it seems to behave like one) and was also commonly known as "petroleum benzine".  It is actually a cocktail of aliphatic hydrocarbons that boil at low temperatures (between 95-140 degrees F).

    I hope this is helpful, Take care, Tom

    --

    Thomas J. Braun

    Senior Objects Conservator

    Minnesota Historical Society



    Peer-reviewed