Connecting to Collections Care

 View Only
  • 1.  effects of roofing tar fumes on collections?

    Posted 09-03-2019 20:34

    The building housing our museum's Exhibitions Center (we are a tenant within a larger commercial complex) has been undergoing major roofing repairs for the last several month, and the work is expected to continue over the next year. The tar fumes are quite noticeable inside the building at times, and have occasionally been unpleasant enough that we have closed to the public. The question of what effect the fumes may have on the artifacts (mixed collections) has come up. We are trying to assess whether the risks inherent in clearing the top floor of all collections and moving them to offsite storage are more or less of a danger than leaving the collections exposed to fumes. I have not been able to find any hard data to support either argument, but my instincts tell me that a major collections move may well be the riskier option, especially since our offsite storage options are not climate controlled and have no fire sprinklers. Do any of the list members have relevant experience and insight?

     

    Thanks,

    Dee

     

    Dee Stubbs-Lee, CAPC, MA

    Conservator / Restauratrice

    New Brunswick Museum/

    Musée du Nouveau-Brunswick

    277 Douglas Avenue

    Saint John, New Brunswick

    E2K 1E5

    Canada

    (506)643-2341

     

     

     

     



  • 2.  RE: effects of roofing tar fumes on collections?

    Posted 09-04-2019 16:27
    Hi Dee,
    Nice framing of this issue as a risk-risk trade off decision. I have no good understanding of the chemical constituents in roofing fumes but I won't let that stop me from offering advice. I suspect the risks associated with a collection move to temporary storage would far outweigh the loss in value to a mixed collection due to such exposure which I expect to be immeasurable. In comparison to many decades of exposure to persistent pollutants (especially reduced sulfur and nitrogen oxide gases), I suspect the added effect of a few months exposure to roofing fumes would not be appreciable (though, as always, I stand to be corrected). In contrast the risks from two (back and forth) collection moves and storage in less than ideal spaces would be both measurable and appreciable.

    Are there possibilities for closing off fresh air intakes while work is progressing?
    Are all reasonable precautions being taken to reduce fire risk resulting from the roofing activities?
    Best,
    Rob
    Robert Waller, PhD, CAPC, FIIC
    President and Senior Risk Analyst
    Protect Heritage Corp.
    622 Simoneau Way
    Ottawa  ON  K4A 1P4



    ------------------------------
    Robert Waller
    President
    Protect Heritage Corp.
    Phoenix AZ
    (613) 883-2707
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: effects of roofing tar fumes on collections?

    Posted 09-05-2019 12:24
    Dee - Rob's post seems reasonable as to the fume risk. I would add that the possible fire risk (assuming the tar is being applied using high heat) might be more of an issue.  Most fires in museums have occurred during construction/renovation.  Very strict control and supervision is essential during this period.  Even though you are only a tenant in the building, you should require that you have input into the process and safety measures.

    Paul Himmelstein

    ------------------------------
    Paul Himmelstein
    Partner
    Appelbaum & Himmelstein
    New York NY
    (212) 666-4630
    ------------------------------