Connecting to Collections Care

 View Only
  • 1.  Command strips on historic woodwork/walls?

    Posted 01-16-2024 14:55

    I work in a 175 year old NHL masonry building that has an event space on the first floor. We are now starting to use the event space significantly more and I've been receiving questions about temporarily attaching things to walls/woodwork for specific events. I've been asked me whether using command strips would be acceptable--does anyone have any experience or thoughts? My gut feeling is that this might be ok on the walls (paint over plaster over brick), but I'm a bit wary of anything stronger than blue tape on the historic woodwork (bookcases, doors etc), because they've been repainted many times  and the paint layers don't always adhere well. But I don't actually know if this approach is overly lenient or overly conservative. Any thoughts from anyone who has dealt with this?



    ------------------------------
    Katherine Haas
    Philadelphia PA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Command strips on historic woodwork/walls?

    Posted 01-16-2024 20:47
      |   view attached

    Hi Katherine,

    As the acting C2C Care community monitor, I'd like to thank you for posting this question to the community. Although the C2C Care program does not endorse any particular manufacturer or product, I invite members to discuss their experiences with these types of requests, products, and any recommendations they have. 

    I've included some technical data from 3M (to be taken with a grain of salt) which might be of use in your decision making. If you haven't already tested the product, try it out on an insignificant surface with a similar texture. 

    3M Command product info sheet - https://docs.rs-online.com/8d0d/0900766b813690ff.pdf

    3M Command product catalog - attached as pdf

    Margaret Sheridan/3M patent for pull-tab stretch release tape - https://patents.google.com/patent/BR0017282A/en 

    Article on how stretch release tape works - https://ifix.gd/31T3Y4d



    ------------------------------
    Sharon Fickeissen
    Connecting to Collections Care Monitor
    Senior Library Conservation Technician
    Hagley Museum & Library
    Wilmington DE
    sfickeissen@hagley.org
    ------------------------------

    Attachment(s)

    pdf
    product-catalogue.pdf   3.19 MB 1 version


  • 3.  RE: Command strips on historic woodwork/walls?

    Posted 01-17-2024 10:34

    Katherine,

    Be wary of blue tape. If it is left up too long even it will affect your surface. I am overly cautious and don't like anything sticky on our historic surfaces. The only exception has been command hooks on stone surfaces to hang Christmas garland. And even that makes me crazy, but it is better than what was done in the past - nails or duck tape!



    ------------------------------
    Gretchen Frick Small
    Director of Programs and Collections
    Butterworth Center & Deere-Wiman House
    Moline IL
    gsmall@butterworthcenter.com
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Command strips on historic woodwork/walls?

    Posted 01-17-2024 10:34

    Hello Katherine, 

    In the past, command strips were used on the walls of our historic house (painted plaster with flat paint) to hold up holiday decorations. This was before my time. However, when they were removed some of them pulled off the paint, and in some instances, a layer of plaster came with it. We no longer hang decorations like they used to. At other places I've worked, we've had success with placing a piece of painters tape on the wall first prior to placing the command strip. We've also hung graphics using velcro with a layer of painters tape between the velcro and wall. I'd be interested to hear what others suggest. 

    Diana



    ------------------------------
    Diana Welsh
    El Retiro Collection Manager
    Bok Tower Gardens
    Lake Wales FL
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Command strips on historic woodwork/walls?

    Posted 01-18-2024 14:10

    Diana, I have had Command strips also pull off layers of paint.  Years ago our Special Events room has lovely woodwork and the holiday party after it was repainted, I recommended using Command Strips for the decorations.  When removing them, you need a slow and steady hand or the foam will tear.  However I found that in some cases, the adhesive can lift paint.  I had only one spot where this happened and was able to find extra paint to inpaint the loss--I was most chagrined to say the least.

    I have used 3M Command strips at home, a most un-historic modern apartment with drywall and cheap paint, and have had problems.  Many strips have lasted at least 10 years in situ, but when removing them, the adhesive mass & its carrier often detach from the foam leaving the slightly discoloured adhesive on the wall surface.  I've had them lift off the paint and paper layer of the drywall.  And I've had things fall...

    I like your idea of using painter's tape as a barrier. 



    ------------------------------
    Bryan Draper
    Special Collections Conservator
    University of Maryland Libraries
    College Park MD
    (804) 564-3100
    ------------------------------