Hi Madeline,
Thank you for your question! In my experience I have yet to find an adhesive that will reliably come off of a painted surface without damage. There is always some risk of peeling off the paint. The adhesive product that I personally have had the most success with is 3Ms Command Strips or similar brand/type of product. The reason these are more effective is that instead of pulling the tape away from the wall at close to a 90 degree angle which requires some force, the tape is first pulled straight down, parallel to the wall surface which allows the tape to stretch loosening the attachment to the wall allowing you to work it off in a slower, more controlled manner. While I've had good success with this, I have also had many mishaps so they are by no means foolproof, and patiently following the directions for removal is critical. If you choose to use any adhesive product I'd recommend using the least amount of attachment you can get away with.
Adhesive products are simple and convenient to use, but I've also found that nails, tacks, or similar hanging hardware can be less damaging than they may seem, especially if you have access to a small amount of touch-up paint. It's much quicker to touch up a few small holes, than a long paint tear. Do you often mount labels in the same location? Could you consider a permanent mount that you could more easily attach and remove labels from? I'm thinking of something like a slotted card holder.
I hope this gives you some ideas to consider.
Best,
Jen
------------------------------
Jen Hunt
Special Collections Conservator
Hesburgh Libraries, University of Notre Dame
jhuntjoh@nd.edu------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 11-17-2025 15:04
From: Madeline Calise
Subject: Labels on walls
Hi C2C community,
I wondered if you had any material suggestions for adhering interpretive labels on a wall in a way that won't rip off the paint when removed. These will be up for a little while so they need to hold up. We've used a type of double sided tape in the past and it usually really rips off the paint. Thanks for your experience.
Madeline